ON THE ISSUES: Border
How do they stand on border issues? Should security override citizens’ desire to travel freely between Northern New York and Canada and the need for smooth commercial travel? Should the federal government interrupt fishing trips, picnics and boating excursions in the name of protecting the border?
DEDE SCOZZAFAVA: We must strike an appropriate balance that recognizes the need for security along the northern border while also remaining mindful of the legitimate commerce and trade that occur every day. Border security policies and procedures justifiably changed after the horrible events of Sept. 11, 2001, but we must recognize the historical, free relationship between the United States and Canada, our largest trading partner. I will work to modernize border-crossing facilities that will reduce wait times, and advocate for pre-clearance screening stations for trucks.
Like most in the north country, I feel that many government regulations are written by people who have never lived or worked in the environment that will be regulated. A prime example is the overburdensome “report in” regulations placed on fishermen, who must show appropriate documentation if they merely drop anchor in Canadian waters. I will also support efforts to harmonize border document crossing requirements for both land and sea travel, including those used by tour boat and fishing captains. However, I will staunchly work with my colleagues to oppose illegal cross-border activities, such as the smuggling of marijuana and cigarettes.
BILL OWENS: We have a unique relationship with our neighbors to the north and our border security policy needs to reflect the realities of that relationship. I do not think there is a “one size fits all” solution to this issue, as what works for us will clearly not work in south Texas. We need to make sure that we are doing all that we can to keep our borders secure but also strike a balance so that we’re not infringing on trade or commerce. I have a deep understanding of border issues as a result of spending decades working to bring Canadian investment to our community. My efforts have resulted in bringing over 200 companies to the region which have helped create 2,000 jobs over the course of that time. Canada plays a significant role in our economy and is a major trading partner, and we cannot take steps that would jeopardize that role.
DOUG HOFFMAN: Sept. 11, 2001 totally changed the dynamic on this issue. We live in an age of terror. In this day and age it would be judicious to defer to the Department of Homeland Security on such issues. That said, I would be a vocal advocate on behalf of my constituents’ needs, both personal and economic, to ensure that crossing between the U.S .and Canada be kept simple and hassle-free as possible.
