A mistrial was declared Thursday in the second-degree assault trial of a town of Rutland man after Jefferson County Court Judge Kim H. Martusewicz determined the jury was hopelessly deadlocked.
Andrew A. Wren, 24, was on trial facing an accusation he punched Colby D. Roy, 26, Watertown, in the face Nov. 24, 2011, at Mr. Wrens residence at 18799 County Route 162. Mr. Roy sustained a broken jaw and lost several teeth.
Mr. Roy maintained he was sucker-punched without provocation by Mr. Wren, who countered he was acting in self-defense. Mr. Roy had gone to the Wren residence to speak with his estranged wife, who had moved in with Mr. Wren about a month earlier.
After a total of about seven hours of deliberation over two days, the jury sent a note to Judge Martusewicz that read, in part, We are deadlocked.
The district attorneys office must now decide whether it will retry the case or see if an alternative disposition can be reached.