Northern New York Newspapers
NNY Business
NNY Living
Tue., Oct. 6
Serving the communities of Jefferson, St. Lawrence and Lewis counties, New York
In print daily. Online always.
Related Stories

Hook-Antlers outdoor column


While attending sportsmen’s shows in Syracuse and Oneida this past winter, I had the chance to visit with Captain Bob Dick who was there with a display for Moby Dick Charters, his sport fishing charter service out of Henderson Harbor. Captain Bob and I are fellow members of the New York State Outdoor Writers Association, but our conversations were not about writing. Instead, the dialogue focused on two interests we have in common: Syracuse basketball and fishing out of Henderson Harbor.

SU Basketball

Captain Bob and I are avid followers of SU hoops, and since the team had Saturday afternoon games during the Syracuse and Oneida shows, the two of us constantly consulted Bob’s wife, Dawn, who was monitoring the games on her cell phone. At that time, Syracuse was in a bit of a slide, but Bob and I agreed that downturns were common over the course of a long season and that the team would turn things around. And rebound they did, as evidenced by their recent performances in the Big East and NCAA tournaments.

What I found most interesting in our conversations about Syracuse basketball was that Coach Jim Boeheim is a regular client of Moby Dick Charters. In fact, the brochure for the charter business includes two photos of the SU coach. He and Jerry MacNamara are displaying an impressive catch of walleyes in one photo while the other picture shows Coach Boeheim with a mixed catch of brown and lake trout. Commenting on the coach’s fishing skills, Captain Bob said, “Coach Boeheim is a really good fisherman.”

Henderson Harbor Fishing

In addition to being fans of SU basketball, Captain Bob and I are fans of Henderson Harbor fishing, and we have sung the area’s praises in many newspaper and magazine articles over the years. In essence, Henderson Harbor is a gateway to world-class fishing.

Captain Bob is a fan because the waters there have allowed him to operate a successful charter service that puts plenty of big fish at line’s end, and big fish translate to happy customers. I am a fan because I love to experience good fishing, and on my numerous trips with Captain Bill Saiff III of Saiff Charters, the fishing has been better than good. It’s been great.

Captain Bob has an intimate knowledge of the fishing out of Henderson Harbor because he spends six days a week from April through September on the water there. I asked him to give an overview of the spring fishing opportunities out of Henderson Harbor so that I could share the information with readers of this column. Here’s what Captain Bob had to say.


“Henderson Harbor may be number-one in the nation for catching trophy walleye. We have been blessed with a fishery that produces 10-14 1/2 pounders consistently. Some of the best places are Campbell’s Shoal, Gull and Bass Islands, the Stony Creek area, and most of the areas around Pillar Point in Black River Bay. Popular stick baits for trolling include Bombers, #18 Rapalas, Thundersticks, Husky Jerks, and Reef Runners, and the best colors are black-silver, blue-silver, and fire tiger. Worm harnesses and crawler tipped jigs also produce excellent catches. In order to help protect the fantastic walleye fishery, more and more anglers are practicing catch and release.”

Brown Trout

“Brown trout fishing has been fantastic the past few springs. Some of the best areas are the sand beach from the mouth of North Sandy Creek and South Sandy Creek to Stony Creek and continuing north anywhere in Sawyer’s Bay, Ray’s Bay, and the shoreline continuing off the trench in to Henderson Harbor. Best trolling depths are between 3 and 30 feet, and favorite lures of the charter captains include Michigan Stingers spoons, Jr. Thundersticks, Smithwicks, and Rapalas.

What is nice about targeting browns is you can also catch a lot of lake trout some days as well as the occasional steelhead.”

Northern Pike

“The northern pike is the bread and butter fish off Henderson Bay in the spring. Just about any spoon or stick bait will catch fish, and popular colors include black, blue, orange, chartreuse, and silver. Some of the best places are the sail boat moorings, White’s Bay, Lime Barrel Shoal, Gull Island, Bass Island, Horse Island, Campbell’s Shoal , and the east shore from Treadwell Point to the Gill House. The best depths are 8-35 feet of water. Use floating lures in the shallows and deep divers or weighted set ups for fishing deeper.”

More Information

Henchen Marina is the center of fishing in Henderson Harbor. The marina has everything to meet an angler’s needs, and since the marina serves as the location where most guides pick up their clients, the folks at Henchen have access to the most up-to-date information on the fishing action. For more information on fishing the Henderson Harbor area, visit,, and


April 7-8—Hunter Education Course at Massena R&G Club (In-person registration with Massena Town Clerk).

April 12-13—Hunter Education Course at Duffany’s Body Shop, Watertown (Pre-register at 788-2161).

April 12-14—Hunter Education Course at Fisher’s Landing Fire Hall (Pre-register at Clayton Library).

April 12-14—Clayton Boat Show at Clayton Arena (686-3771).

April 13—Hunter Education Course at Beaver River F&G Club (Pre-register at Buckingham Hardware, Croghan).

April 13-14—Massena R&G Club hosts annual Sportsmen’s Expo.

April 20—Hunter Education Course at Moose River F&G Club (Pre-register at 351-6673).

April 25-27—Hunter Education Course at Dexter/Brownville (Pre-register at 785-2533).

April 27—Hunter Education Course at Dexter (Pre-register at 649-5977).

May 4—St. Lawrence River Walleye Association hosts Opening Day Derby (384-3450).

May 4—St. Lawrence Valley Sportsmen’s Club hosts annual Opening Day Walleye Derby.

May 25—Cape Vincent C of C hosts Annual Spring Fishing Derby (654-2481).

Commenting rules:
  1. Stick to the topic of the article/letter/editorial.
  2. When responding to issues raised by other commenters, do not engage in personal attacks or name-calling.
  3. Comments that include profanity/obscenities or are libelous in nature will be removed without warning.
Violators' commenting privileges may be revoked indefinitely. By commenting you agree to our full Terms of Use.
Syracuse Football Tickets Giveaway
Connect with Us
WDT News FeedsWDT on FacebookWDT on TwitterWDT on InstagramWDT for iOS: iPad, iPhone, and iPod touchWDT for Android
Showcase of Homes
Showcase of Homes