The state Assembly passed legislation this week that would let New Yorkers cast ballots two weeks in advance of Election Day.
But the legislation making New York the 33rd early voting state has been met with hostility by some who fear early voting will raise the price of elections for counties.
This again is Albany passing down an unfunded mandate, Assemblyman Kenneth J. Blankenbush, R-Black River, said. Mr. Blankenbush voted against the bill.
Mr. Blankenbush said the bill would require that counties establish five polling places that are open for 14 days without state funding to pay for it.
Im not going to vote for any unfunded mandate, he said.
Assemblyman Marc W. Butler, R-Newport, also voted against the legislation in part because he thinks its not tailored to meet the needs of the north country.
Mr. Butler said Hamilton County, which he also represents, has a population of 5,000 and would have to establish five polling places for early voting, the same as more populated counties.
There would be absolutely no benefits in the upstate areas, he said.
Of the north country delegation, only Assemblywoman Addie J. Russell, D-Theresa, voted for the measure.
I think we all recognize that there is much lower voter participation in our elections than there should be. This legislation starts the dialog in order to encourage more voting, she said.
Mrs. Russell also said the costs associated with the legislation could be mitigated by adding flexibility into future legislation. She said she believes that consolidating the number of polling places in addition to keeping them open longer may alleviate some of the financial burden associated with early voting.
Jennie H. Bacon, St. Lawrence County Board of Elections Democratic commissioner, said although early voting may cost the county more, I think it would be a great opportunity for our voters.
New York state is ranked 47th in the nation in voter turnout, Mrs. Bacon said. St. Lawrence Countys average turnout is lower than the statewide turnout.
In the 2012 general election, Mrs. Bacon said, 62 percent of county voters voted, compared with 34 percent in 2011 when there wasnt a presidential election.
On the other side of the aisle, Republican Elections Commissioner Thomas A. Nichols condemned the measure. He said he doesnt think early voting will help with voter turnout.
Theres a reason that people arent turning out to vote. People are disgusted by the process, he said. They dont need more days to vote.
In the state Senate, the bills prospects are dim, according to north country senators.
I dont think its going anywhere in the Senate, said Sen. Joseph A. Griffo, R-Rome. Sens. Elizabeth OC. Little, R-Queensbury, and Patricia A. Ritchie, R-Heuvelton, agreed.
It isnt all partisan stonewalling, however. While Democrats and Republicans in the north country are divided over this piece of legislation, they agree more flexibility for counties would be a positive step forward in future bills.
Mr. Butler said he thinks exemptions for smaller counties may be in order.
Were really two states tied together by one government, Mr. Butler said of the divide between upstate and downstate.
Mr. Griffo said he is interested in possible changes to the day elections are held and making absentee ballots more accessible.
Maybe they should be on Sunday or Saturday, he said.
Mr. Griffo said more avenues should be investigated before any laws are passed.
Mrs. Ritchie agreed.
It looks like the best way to generate higher voter turnout would be to look at improving our absentee voter system, she said. Its too complicated.