Comments by Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo about siting prospective casinos pleased St. Lawrence County lawmakers who feel the county has been wronged in the dispute over the state-tribal gaming compact.
Its nice to see the governor taking an active part in seeing that the compact is held up, said Jonathan S. Putney, D-Waddington, chairman of the Board of Legislators.
Gov. Cuomo said Thursday that Indian casinos in the state could see competition from state-sponsored gaming operations if lingering disputes are not settled soon.
State legislators and Gov. Cuomo are considering legislation and a public referendum that would allow non-Indian casinos. Gov. Cuomo has divided the state into six regions for prospective casinos. Three of the regions already have Indian casinos. The governor has said that casinos would not be allowed in locations surrounding Indian casinos if the tribes that operate them were in good standing with the state.
The St. Regis Mohawk tribe, which operates the Akwesasne Mohawk Casino Resort, stopped payments on a compact with the state in 2010, claiming its exclusivity had been breached by a gaming operation on the Ganienkeh reservation near Plattsburgh.
As a result, more than $12 million is owed to St. Lawrence and Franklin counties and the towns of Massena, Brasher, Bombay and Fort Covington.
In the end, St. Lawrence County has suffered, said Legislator Vernon D. Sam Burns, D-Ogdensburg, who has been active in pursuing a casino for Ogdensburg. However it gets resolved, then we can go forward. St. Lawrence County shouldnt be squeezed. Its good its being discussed.
St. Regis Mohawks, busy with the grand opening Thursday of a $74 million casino and resort expansion, had no immediate reaction to Gov. Cuomos comments.
We just havent had enough time to look at the issue, tribal spokesman David T. Staddon said.
Exactly what good standing means remains unclear.
The Seneca Nation, which operates casinos in Buffalo, Niagara Falls and Salamanca, also has stopped payment to the state, claiming violations of its exclusivity rights like the Mohawks; but the Oneida Nation, which runs Turning Stone Resort and Casino in Central New York, has no pact that requires revenue sharing or an exclusive territory. Gov. Cuomo suggested the Oneidas could avoid state competition by settling land claims.
In addition to the state-tribal compact dispute, St. Regis Mohawks have had disputes with the state over land claims and cigarette taxes.
The wording in good standing, what does that mean? I guess its a matter of opinion, Mr. Burns said. It should be resolved.
While the governors words were encouraging to St. Lawrence legislators, the county still is considering a lawsuit to recoup its lost compact money. Legislators recently delayed a decision so attorneys could conduct a further review.
All options remain on the table, and well continue to evaluate the situation, Mr. Putney said.
Gov. Cuomo also pushed the idea of future casinos sharing revenues with the counties surrounding them, not necessarily just with the one in which they were located. The concept could make passage of a referendum measure easier.
It also could mean legislators coalesce around a location rather than vie with each other. While St. Lawrence officials have pushed for a casino in Ogdensburg, a racino a harness racetrack with a casino has been proposed for Alexandria Bay.
Agreement on a location and revenue sharing would depend on the details, Mr. Burns said.
If were talking an equal share, Im not sure thats fair to the county its located in, he said. Im OK with Ogdensburg getting a casino. I think its fair to say we could share some of the revenue with our neighboring counties. Im not completely opposed.